Exclusively Setters

Home for Irish Setter Lovers Around the World

human friend
  • Australia
Share
  • Blog Posts
  • Discussions (37)
  • Events
  • Groups
  • Photos
  • Photo Albums
  • Videos

Human friend's Friends

  • Catherine Carter

human friend's Discussions

Anti-chewing spray recipe

Started this discussion. Last reply by human friend Nov 17, 2016. 3 Replies

My dog is still chewing rocks and swallowing them and the only solution, in this area, is a water-resistant spray. Any ideas? I have read about bitter apple and tabasco, but I need to devise…Continue

Need Help NOW - cat litter eaten!

Started this discussion. Last reply by human friend Oct 6, 2016. 6 Replies

I know this is potentially really bad, one or two or three of my dogs has eaten 80% of a standard tray of CLUMPING CORN LITTER. What do I do? I know this can cause blockages .. . I'm thinking a…Continue

My Dog Just Pooed Out a Rock!

Started this discussion. Last reply by human friend Jul 7, 2016. 5 Replies

Poor thing, he looks confused but also a little proud now.This morning he was lethargic, not eating and occasionally vomiting but with no temperature or sign of pain.This afternoon he had some watery…Continue

How do I fix this nail?

Started this discussion. Last reply by Jennifer Sellek Nov 21, 2016. 4 Replies

Yesterday my red Irish, who is 4, got one of the claws on his front paw snagged in some hessian. I managed to free it eventually but the thread was jammed in because he has a split longitudinally…Continue

Gifts Received

Gift

human friend has not received any gifts yet

Give a Gift

 

human friend's Page

Profile Information

How many Irish Setters do you have?
3
How long have you owned Irish Setters?
twenty odd years
About Me:
These are my dogs. I am their human friend.
Why are you applying for membership?
A. I am a human wanting to contribute to the community

Comment Wall (5 comments)

At 8:26am on March 24, 2016, human friend said…
this site is hardly active
At 7:23am on March 25, 2016, James Doran said…

Lets make things a little more active then, human friend. Why don't you tell us a little about yourself and your dogs, and maybe post a few photos!

At 7:09am on March 26, 2016, Catherine Carter said…

we could start a dialogue if you tell us about your dogs and yourself !

At 6:11am on August 31, 2016, Mike O'Dwyer said…

Hi Human Friend, sorry for the delay in replying –work and home schedules kinda crazy lately!!

Re. whether or not there is greater type-variation among IR&WS than in Irish Setters, whilst I am not an authority on either breed, I would say that you may be broadly correct.  In my own experience to date, many working IR&WS tend to be somewhat lighter, smaller and with less coat than many specimens from show kennels which may have been selectively bred for ‘improvement’ in these and other aspects over a number of generations.  Whilst there isn’t supposed to be any appreciable difference between ‘show’ and ‘working’ dogs (indeed many good specimens regularly fulfil BOTH roles), and judges are supposed to evaluate show exhibits primarily from a working perspective, nevertheless, from what I have so far seen, many judges either aren’t aware of this or choose to ignore it, as some of the regularly-winning dogs show some physical exaggerations in being over-sized in body, head, heaviness of bone, length of coat and tail carriage, etc.. 

It seems likely also, that the greater variation among IR&WS can at least in part be attributed to the out-crossing with Irish red Setters which has been essential up to the present time in order to broaden the IR&WS gene pool. The differences in head shape, length of coat and overall impression of Reds (eg., ‘Racey’, compared with ‘Athletic’ in IR&WS), logically has to influence ‘type’ in out-crossed IR&WS, potentially for a number of generations, obviously depending on how well breeders select sound ‘typical’ IR&WS stud dog specimens to breed back to in the post out-cross generations, and of course allowing for natural variations in type (as with any other breed), which  occur despite the best efforts of breeders, and also the phenomenon of ‘throw-back’ individuals appearing sporadically in a litter.  Additionally, whether the variation in shade/intensity of the red ‘islands’ in the coats of IR&WS (eg., ‘Chestnut’ red as opposed to darker red), is in any way attributable to the out-crossing, or whether it has always been a feature of the IR&WS breed, I have so far been unable to ascertain.  The offical  breed standard (ie., from the country of origin: Ireland), specifies the essential coat characteristic of white predominating, with ‘islands’ or patches of red, but some individuals have a marked excess of red in the coat – as a long-standing breeder friend put it to me, “…the coat should have islands of red, not continents of it…”.

But hey, whilst it is obviously important for breeders and fanciers to strive for maintenance of type and general soundness in the conservation and furtherance of any breed (temperament and health notwithstanding), an ‘imperfect’ specimen can turn out to be as good, and possibly better, canine companion as any ‘stunner’ (as with humans, I guess J), even if it might be omitted from a breeding programme.  This answer to your question should not be taken as definitive at all, but I hope it might be of some help. Mike.

At 5:50am on September 7, 2016, Mike O'Dwyer said…

Did my response help at all?  Mike

You need to be a member of Exclusively Setters to add comments!

Join Exclusively Setters

 
 
 

Badge

Loading…

© 2017   Created by Gene.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service